| Home | E-Submission | Sitemap | Contact Us |  
The Nerve > Volume 7(2); 2021 > Article
Jang and Kang: Differentiation between Spinal Intramedullary Astrocytoma and Spinal Multiple Sclerosis Using Clinical and Radiologic Factors



Both spinal multiple sclerosis (SMS) and spinal intramedullary astrocytoma (SIA) are rare space-occupying lesions in the spinal cord and clinically show various myelopathy symptoms. Both clinical and imaging findings are similar and are easily misdiagnosed. This study is to clarify clinical and radiographic finding that could be helpful to differentiate SMS from SIA.


We compared the demographic, clinical, and radiographic characteristics between the SIA and SMS groups. The SIA group (n=13) was diagnosed postoperatively with pathologic confirmation, and the SMS group (n=25) was composed of patients who have a lesion in the spinal cord and met the McDonald criteria for the diagnosis of multiple sclerosis (criteria revised in 2010).


Clinically, patients with SIA had a significantly longer symptom duration before the first visit than SMS (4.9±4.4 vs. 2.1±3.6 months, p=0.008). All persons with SIA showed progressive disease course, whereas 95.8% of persons with SMS showed remission (p<0.001). In contrast to SMS, the involvement of both halves of the spinal cord was more frequently observed in patients with SIA (p<0.001). In addition, fusiform dilation in the sagittal plane (p<0.001) or tumoral cyst (p=0.001) also significantly suggested SIA rather than SMS.


Despite many limitations of this study, the present data demonstrated the clinical and imaging features helpful in distinguishing SIA from SMS. As with most tumors, SIA tends to show a slowly progressive clinical course without remission. Occupation of both halves of the spinal cord, fusiform dilation, or cysts was favoring radiographic factor for the SIA.


Multiple sclerosis (MS) is the most common demyelinating disease in the central nervous system(CNS). It often involves the spinal cord with 74% to 95% in established MS11). Although the prevalence of spinal cord abnormality is lower in clinically isolated syndromes, 30% to 40% of these patients also had asymptomatic lesions. An acute demyelinating event is often represented on magnetic resonance imaging(MRI) by solitary or multifocal hyperintensities on T2-weighted images (T2-WI) with a variable pattern of enhancement, challenging the distinction of demyelination from intramedullary neoplasms. Differentiation of these two diseases is of great importance in selecting treatment modalities and predicting the patient’s prognosis. Although numerous reports have been described the suggestive MRI findings of each disease, a comparative radiological study between these two diseases has rarely been accomplished or has only provided an obscure description. Therefore, in many cases, the differentiation of MS from intramedullary glioma without biopsy has been made without confidence due to similarities in imaging features. This study compares the clinical presentation and radiographic features between MS and intramedullary astrocytoma in the spinal cord.


The Institutional Review Board approved this study. This study is a retrospective design that does not involve an intervention, and the patient’s written consent was waived.

1. Patients

Between January 2004 and December 2013, spinal intramedullary astrocytoma (SIA) patients were identified based on surgical records and pathologic results in our institutional data set. The spinal MS (SMS) patient group was searched for “multiple sclerosis” as the inpatient and outpatient records diagnosis. The patients who have one or more lesions in the spinal cord and meet the McDonald criteria for MS were included. McDonald Criteria was used with the version revised in 201014). Patients who are positive for neuromyelitis optica antibody or acute viral markers like IgM for herpes simplex virus were excluded. Patients who have a history of autoimmune diseases like systemic lupus erythematosus were also excluded.

2. Radiographic Features

Two neurosurgeons (MSK, HJ) evaluated the MRI images on a picture archiving and communication system workstation monitor concerning longitudinal and axial locations, size of the lesion on T2-WI, portion and pattern of enhancement, fusiform dilatation, and the presence of syringomyelia, tumoral cyst, or hemorrhage.
The lesion’s longitudinal location was assessed by the dominant portion of involvement among the cervical, thoracic, and lumbar regions. Axial location was classified as the involvement of a single half or both halves of the spinal cord. The size of the lesion was measured in the number of vertebral segments involved in T2-WI. The enhancing portion was classified as non-enhanced, focal, and diffuse. It was evaluated as diffuse if the lesion’s enhancing component was 50% larger than the entire high intensity on T2-WI, focal if smaller than 50%, or none. The pattern of contrast enhancement was classified into four patterns: solid, if the contour of the enhancing component is clear: patchy, if the contour is vague, or unclear: the rim, if only the marginal area is enhanced: or punctate if the enhancing pattern was dot-like. Fusiform dilatation was determined by whether the thickness of the cord was significantly increased compared with the peripheral area in the sagittal plane. Syringomyelia was defined as cystic dilatation of the central portion of the spinal cord without any enhancement. If a cyst was seen in the solid portion of the lesion, whether it appears centrally or peripherally, it was regarded as a tumoural cyst. A rim of extreme low signal intensity was seen at the tumor’s proximal or distal pole on T2-WI, suggesting haemosiderin deposits; it was defined as hemorrhage.

3. Demographic and Clinical Features

Demographic (sex and age) and clinical information were collected for all participants from patient records. Pathological findings in patients who underwent surgery were also reviewed. The clinical course and final diagnosis for each participant were investigated. Clinical features of neurological deficits (motor, sensory, pain, autonomic, visual symptoms) were also investigated.

4. Statistical Analysis

All analyses were performed with SPSS version 20.0 (IBM Corp., Armonk, NY, USA). Demographic data of SIA and SMS groups were assessed by Fisher’s exact test, student t-test, and the preoperative results and clinical data were assessed by the Mann-Whitney test. All p-values less than 0.05 were considered statistically significant.


1. Clinical Features

In SIA, 13 lesions were identified in 13 patients, and SMS was recognized in 31 lesions in 25 patients.
SIA group had seven low-grade and six high-grade astrocytomas. Table 1 compares the clinical features. The mean age was 34.9±15.7 years in SIA patients and 42.1±15.4 years in SMS patients. There was no significant difference in sex ratio. Compared with the time interval from the onset of the symptoms to visit the clinic, the SIA group showed a significantly longer duration (4.9±4.4 vs. 2.1±3.6months, p=0.008). The clinical course also showed a significant difference between the two groups. In the SIA group, all patients showed a progressive course, whereas only one patient in the SMS group showed a primary progressive pattern (p<0.001). Seven patients of the SMS group had a clinically isolated syndrome and remained clinically stable. Seventeen patients had a relapsing-remitting pattern but showed partial recovery during the deterioration period. The most common symptom was a weakness of the extremities, followed by sensory change and axial pain. There was no difference in the ratio of the clinical symptoms in both groups (Fig. 1).

2. Radiographic Features

Table 2 compares the radiographic features. In the SIA group, the incidence of infiltration of both halves of the spinal cord in the axial plane was 100%, but only 40% in the SMS group had both infiltrations (p<0.001). Besides, all SIA patients showed fusiform dilatation of the spinal cord in the sagittal plane, which occurred in only 45.2% of the SMS patients (p<0.001). The tumoral cyst was not observed in persons with SMS, but it was identified in 5 cases among 13 persons with SIA(p=0.001). There was no difference in the location or the length of the lesion, portion or pattern of enhancement, presence of syrinx, or hemorrhage.


SMS is an immune-mediated, demyelinating disease of the CNS, and it is usually called a tumefactive lesion because it imitates a spinal cord tumor, including SIA. Despite the development of MRI, there are no established criteria to discriminate the two disease entities preoperatively. Clinically, both diseases were reported to have similar symptoms, a nonspecific combination of neurologic deficits like quadri- or para-paresis, sensory disturbance, and autonomic symptoms1,5).
However, there were two different clinical features in disease progression between the two groups. First, while most SMS groups showed a period of symptom resolution after a clinical attack, all SIA persons showed continuous progression. MS is divided into four categories as described below; Relapsing-remitting, primary progressive, secondary progressive, progressive-relapsing type. The relapsing-remitting type, which has a flare-up period of symptom followed by a recovery time, is most common, affecting 85% to 90% of MS5). Although the course of SMS is highly variable, 95.8% of SMS patients in this series experienced a temporary symptomatic improvement after the first attack1,10,12). On the contrary, SIA may have an expansile characteristic so that the spinal cord is gradually pressed to show clinical deterioration2). Brinar et al.4) analyzed five patients and reported a similar pattern.
Second, persons with SIA took a relatively long time to visit the hospital after symptoms. The progress of SIA is mainly known to be slow, especially in low-grade tumors. It takes a significantly longer time for the low-grade tumor to be diagnosed after the onset of symptoms than in the high-grade17,18). Thus, even if a tumor develops, it takes a relatively long time for subsequent symptoms to occur1,13). While SIA gradually progresses to develop symptoms over the years2), clinical features that suggest demyelination have an acute or subacute onset over days to weeks, within average four to seven weeks5,10).
The spinal cord is a small, pulsating structure that adds technical difficulties to MRI. The low relevance of MRI findings to clinical symptoms is also a source of distress11). Moreover, there is no large-scale study on the susceptibility score because the incidence is very low compared with brain lesions. These diseases may also have a heterogeneous appearance due to clinical course or phase21). While there appears to be no unique radiologic difference SIA and SMS, some image findings can be used as a discriminatory reference.
Involving both halves of the spinal cord in the axial plane was significantly lower in the SMS group. Eckstein commented in their differential CNS demyelination strategy from MS that SMS often involves only a partial cross-sectional area of the spinal cord with less than two vertebral bodies7). Brinar et al.4) suggested that MRI of SMS is featured by small, well-circumscribed, asymmetrically involving, focal T2-hyperintensity lesions as a differential approach to spinal cord enlargement. Tartaglino et al.20) analyzed 124 demyelinating plaques in sixty-eight patients and reported 81 percent of lesions occupied less than half of the cord’s cross-sectional area. In contrast, most astrocytomas were usually located in the central portion or involved the entire cord6,19). Because astrocytoma is predominantly involved in the central and dorsal portion of the entire cord, the surgical technique description recommends a common approach through the dorsal median sulcus9).
Fusiform dilatation helps in differentiating between SMS and SIA. Spinal cord enlargement is rarely seen in non-neoplastic lesions8,18). Abd-El-Barr et al.1) emphasized in their review of SIA that infiltrating astrocytomas often appear expansile, hypo- to iso-intense on T1, and hyperintense on T2. If the lesion shows mass effect or cord expansion, it is recommended that SIA be raised as a differential diagnosis4,6,15,19). In the illustrative cases, the fusiform dilatation filling the entire spinal canal was observed in persons with SIA, and the lesion involved both halves. In contrast, the SMS had four vertebral bodies but relatively more minor fusiform dilatation, and only the left eccentric location was shown in an axial plane (Fig. 2, 3).
Cysts are present in 25% to 40% of spinal cord neoplasms6,15). The presence of a cyst can be interpreted as suggesting that the possibility of SMS is low. In particular, astrocytomas demonstrate tumor cysts more frequently than other intramedullary tumors16). In our study, no cyst was observed in the SMS group, consistent with previous literature. However, a comprehensive judgment is required because there is a rare case report that cyst is accompanied by SMS3), and it may appear indistinguishable from solid tumors on T2-WI as a consequence of the high protein content of the cyst fluid.
Contrast-enhanced images help the differential diagnosis15,20), but this study did not show any difference between the two groups. Syringomyelia or hemorrhage also did not show significant differences. Based on the above two clinical and three radiologic characteristics, the differential diagnosis prediction model showed high sensitivity and specificity. While it is difficult to accept the accuracy of the prediction model because of a relatively small number of subjects, it is reasonable to give meaning to the clinical and radiographic factors mentioned above.
In addition to the retrospective study design, this study has several other limitations. First, this study analyzes a small number of patients, including the 13 SIAs and 25 SMS patients, and consequently, it is not free from selection bias. Second, although astrocytoma’s clinical course differs between low-grade and high-grade, the incidence of spinal cord lesions is very low, so in this study, the two diseases were classified into one group. Third, this study has heterogeneity by including both 1.5 Tesla (T) and 3T MRI and advanced MRI techniques, which have higher sensitivity, such as diffusion-weighted imaging and diffusion tensor imaging were not included. In T2-WI, the probability of finding a cord lesion was reduced due to pulsation artifact, and spinal cord lesions usually do not show low intensity on T1 images due to the spinal cord’s dense organization1). However, it is inevitable because of the rare incidence of both diseases. Nevertheless, the existing researches on this subject were sparse, so that the clinical meaning of this study can be adequately strengthened.


In this study, clinical features and imaging characteristics were compared through a series of SIA and SMS patients. Whereas SMS patients had a remission period between acute exacerbations, whereas SIA patients showed a progressive course. The majority of the SIA occupied both halves of the spinal cord. Fusiform dilation or tumoral cyst was a common finding in SIA. However, additional studies based on large patients and advanced imaging are needed to validate these findings.

Conflicts of Interest


No potential conflict of interest relevant to this article was reported.

Fig. 1
Comparing spinal intramedullary astrocytoma (SIA) and spinal multiple sclerosis (SMS) symptoms, there was no significant difference in symptom ratios between the 2 groups.
Fig. 2
An illustrative case of spinal multiple sclerosis (SMS). Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of a 31-year-old female with quadriparesis for 2 months. T2-weighted image (T2-WI) showed the 4-segment length of the high-intensity lesion with focal enhancement. (A, B) In the axial plane, only the left dorsal was infiltrated. (C, D) Despite conservative treatment with steroid pulse therapy for 3 months, the lesion showed progression. She underwent surgical resection of the lesion, and the pathologic report revealed multifocal perivascular lymphocytic infiltration. T2-WI in brain MRI in the postoperative period showed juxtacortical lesions (E).
Fig. 3
An illustrative case of spinal intramedullary astrocytoma (SIA). The 23-year-old male complained of progressive both hand weakness for 9 months. In preoperative magnetic resonance imaging, the fusiform dilatation and infiltration of both halves were definite. (A, C) The contrast enhancement was not prominent. (B, D) Due to the progressive clinical course, he underwent surgical removal of the tumor and was diagnosed with intramedullary anaplastic astrocytoma.
Table 1
Comparison of the clinical factors of the groups
Variables Spinal intramedullary astrocytoma Spinal multiple sclerosis p-value
Patients 13 25
Lesions 13 31
Age (years) 34.9±15.7 42.1±15.4 0.183
Sex (male:female) 8 : 5 8 : 17 0.098
Symptom duration to visit (months) 4.9±4.4 2.1±3.6 0.008*
Clinical course Progressive, non-remitting 100% Non-remitting 3.2% <0.001*

The data is presented as mean±standard deviation or number.

* The difference between the values of both groups was statistically significant.

Table 2
Comparison of the radiographic factors of the groups
Variables Spinal intramedullary astrocytoma Spinal multiple sclerosis p-value
Location (cervical : thoracic : conus) 8 : 4 : 1 17 : 12 : 2 0.879
Involved segment (vertebral body) 3.0±1.4 3.0±1.9 0.461
Infiltration of both halves of the spinal cord in axial plane 13 (100.0%) 12 (38.7%) <0.000*
Fusiform dilatation 13 (100.0%) 14 (45.2%) <0.000*
Portion of enhancement (non : focal : diffuse) 2 : 3 : 8 5 : 13 : 6 0.104
Pattern of Enhancement (patchy : rim : solid : punctate) 7 : 2 : 2 : 2 10 : 3 : 6 : 5 0.857
Syringomyelia 2 (15.4%) 1 (3.2%) 0.204
Tumoural cyst 5 (38.5% ) 0 (0%) 0.001*
Hemorrhage 3 (23.1%) 1 (3.2%) 0.071

* The difference between the values of both groups was statistically significant.


1. Abd-El-Barr MM, Huang KT, Chi JH: Infiltrating spinal cord astrocytomas: Epidemiology, diagnosis, treatments and future directions. J Clin Neurosci 29:15-20, 2016
crossref pmid
2. Bowers DC, Weprin BE: Intramedullary spinal cord tumors. Curr Treat Options Neurol 5:207-212, 2003
crossref pmid
3. Braverman DL, Lachmann EA, Tunkel R, Nagler W: Multiple sclerosis presenting as a spinal cord tumor. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 78:1274-1276, 1997
crossref pmid
4. Brinar M, Rados M, Habek M, Poser CM: Enlargement of the spinal cord: Inflammation or neoplasm? Clin Neurol Neurosurg 108:284-289, 2006
crossref pmid
5. Brownlee WJ, Hardy TA, Fazekas F, Miller DH: Diagnosis of multiple sclerosis: Progress and challenges. Lancet 389:1336-1346, 2017
6. Do-Dai DD, Brooks MK, Goldkamp A, Erbay S, Bhadelia RA: Magnetic resonance imaging of intramedullary spinal cord lesions: a pictorial review. Curr Probl Diagn Radiol 39:160-185, 2010
crossref pmid
7. Eckstein C, Saidha S, Levy M: A differential diagnosis of central nervous system demyelination: beyond multiple sclerosis. J Neurol 259:801-816, 2012
8. Hardy TA, Chataway J: Tumefactive demyelination: an approach to diagnosis and management. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 84:1047-1053, 2013
crossref pmid
9. Jallo GI, Kothbauer KF, Epstein FJ: Intrinsic spinal cord tumor resection. Neurosurgery 49:1124-1128, 2001
crossref pmid
10. Lucchinetti CF, Gavrilova RH, Metz I, Parisi JE, Scheithauer BW, Weigand S, et al: Clinical and radiographic spectrum of pathologically confirmed tumefactive multiple sclerosis. Brain 131:1759-1775, 2008
crossref pmid pmc
11. Lycklama G, Thompson A, Filippi M, Miller D, Polman C, Fazekas F, et al: Spinal-cord MRI in multiple sclerosis. Lancet Neurol 2:555-562, 2003
crossref pmid
12. Makary MS, Kirsch CF: Tumefactive demyelinating disease with isolated spinal cord involvement. Acta Radiol Short Rep 3:20479816145393242014
13. Mishima K, Nakamura M, Nakamura H, Nakamura O, Funata N, Shitara N: Leptomeningeal dissemination of cerebellar pilocytic astrocytoma. Case report J Neurosurg 77:788-791, 1992
crossref pmid
14. Polman CH, Reingold SC, Banwell B, Clanet M, Cohen JA, Filippi M, et al: Diagnostic criteria for multiple sclerosis: 2010 revisions to the McDonald criteria. Ann Neurol 69:292-302, 2011
crossref pmid pmc
15. Rogers SR, Phalke VV, Anderson J, Riccelli LP, Gonda S, Pollock JM: HEALSME: Differential diagnosis for intramedullary spinal cord lesions. Neurographics 2:13-26, 2012
16. Roonprapunt C, Houten JK: Spinal cord astrocytomas: presentation, management, and outcome. Neurosurg Clin N Am 17:29-36, 2006
crossref pmid
17. Ryu SJ, Kim JY, Kim KH, Park JY, Kuh SU, Chin DK, et al: A retrospective observational study on the treatment outcomes of 26 patients with spinal cord astrocytoma including two cases of malignant transformation. Eur Spine J 25:4067-4079, 2016
crossref pmid
18. Schwartz TH, McCormick PC: Non-neoplastic intramedullary pathology. Diagnostic dilemma: to Bx or not to Bx. J Neurooncol 47:283-292, 2000
19. Seo HS, Kim JH, Lee DH, Lee YH, Suh SI, Kim SY, et al: Nonenhancing intramedullary astrocytomas and other MR imaging features: a retrospective study and systematic review. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol 31:498-503, 2010
crossref pmid pmc
20. Tartaglino LM, Friedman DP, Flanders AE, Lublin FD, Knobler RL, Liem M: Multiple sclerosis in the spinal cord: MR appearance and correlation with clinical parameters. Radiology 195:725-732, 1995
crossref pmid
21. Thorpe JW, Kidd D, Moseley IF, Kenndall BE, Thompson AJ, MacManus DG, et al: Serial gadolinium-enhanced MRI of the brain and spinal cord in early relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis. Neurology 46:373-378, 1996
crossref pmid
Editorial Office
Department of Neurosurgery, Dankook University Hospital
201, Manghyang-ro, Dongnam-gu, Cheonan-si, Chungcheongnam-do 31116, South Korea
TEL: +82-41-550-7060   FAX: +82-41-550-7060   E-mail: spine1225@naver.com
About |  Browse Articles |  Current Issue |  For Authors and Reviewers
Copyright © The Korean Society of Peripheral Nervous System.                 Developed in M2PI